I get the feeling that judges and legislators around the country are starting their summers early because my Lexis feed was very slow this month. Here's what I found.
Mootness Can Work Against Lazy Plaintiffs
In earlier posts, I’ve mentioned that it’s very difficult to win a mootness claim in a web accessibility case. This is because websites are complicated and always in flux—so it’s hard to say that all of the violations have been removed and not likely to recur (the general standard required for mootness). If you’re a plaintiff facing a motion to dismiss based on mootness, however, you can still lose if you don’t put up a decent fight. This was made clear this month in Toro v. Medbar Corp., 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 91815 (S.D.N.Y. 2024). In Medbar, a serial plaintiff sued an online company after he was unable to buy a motorcycle helmet for his friend. The company moved to dismiss and submitted an affidavit from the store manager that all of the alleged violations had been fixed and would not happen again. The magistrate judge stated,
"In similar ADA website cases, courts in this District have ruled that a sworn statement by a company official with direct knowledge of the allegations describing the steps taken to remedy the violations and the measures in place going forward to prevent future violations is sufficient grounds for determining the violations have been cured and are extremely unlikely to recur"
id, at *7, and dismissed the case. Based on my earlier post, I don’t agree with this statement—simply saying that you’ve fixed the problems and describing how they won’t happen again is rarely enough—but it’s a great quote for any defendant raising a mootness claim.
But this analysis is spot on if you’re dealing with a lazy plaintiff who doesn’t put up an adequate fight. In this case, Mr. Toro reiterated the allegations he made in his complaint and offered no new evidence that violations continued to exist on the Medbar website. It is always possible to lose an easy case if you don't try to win it.
Colorado HB 24-1454 Extension Signed by Governor
On Friday, May 24, Governor Jared Polis signed HB 24-1454 that provides a one-year grace period of compliance with HB 21-1110 and its requirement for Colorado public entities to make their websites and digital technologies comply with WCAG 2.1 A/AA. This means that Colorado public entities can qualify for an extension until July 1, 2025 to make their websites and digital technologies comply with WCAG 2.1 A/AA before they can be sued for $3,500 per violation.
Exactly how to qualify for the extension, however, is a debated question. At the bottom of my blog post announcing the extension, I describe the controversy. The bottom line is that earning the extension isn’t automatic.
Other Developments this Month
Only a few other cases this month are worth mentioning.
- In Murphy v. Rolex Watch USA, Inc., 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 84515 (W.D. Pa. 2024), a magistrate judge dismissed an ADA web lawsuit against a Swiss watch manufacturer because the plaintiff had not identified a nexus between the allegedly inaccessible website and a physical place of public accommodation. This is consistent with other recent cases from the Western District of Pennsylvania using the nexus approach.
- In Mercedes v. Broadway Play Publishing, Inc., 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 94508 (S.D.N.Y. 2024), the court considered whether a serial plaintiff had a genuine “intent to return” and, instead of dismissing the case, ordered a limited discovery period on this issue and an in-person evidentiary hearing. I’m not a fan of New York’s “intent to return” approach, but I do think this Court’s approach makes more sense because it gives genuine plaintiffs an opportunity to prove their interest in a defendant's products instead of just focusing on the words on the complaint.
Disclaimer
Nothing in this post should be interpreted as legal advice or as forming an attorney-client relationship. It is offered for educational purposes only. You should always contact a qualified attorney in your area to discuss your legal rights and responsibilities.
Want to See More Content Like This?
Want the latest blog posts, videos, white papers, and announcements? Sign up for our mailing list and stay in the loop!
We're Here to Help When You're Ready
Take a deep breath. Then feel free to reach out to our team when you're ready to discuss your accessibility needs.





0 comments on “Legal Update: May 2024”